While YTB will likely find one thing to positively spin about this report, it is clear that the company is in dire straits. Below are the excerpts from the
YTB 10K for 2009. The number in parenthesis is the page where it can be found (it is the PDF page number and not the report page number). My observations are in bold.
YTB Franchise Services, Inc. (― YTB Franchise ‖) was formed in March 2009, to serve as the corporate entity to offer a new franchise offering designed to increase the training and qualifications of those IBC owners who want to focus exclusively on travel. There has been no activity by YTB Franchise other than an initial capital contribution by YTB International, Inc. All intercompany transactions have been eliminated in consolidation. Franchise applications have been filed in 7 states and are pending approval. (9/165)
Does not seem like franchising travel is a priority for YTB. RTA/TSOs were told it was happening in early 2008.
As of April 7, 2010, we had a total of 157 full-time employees, 3 part-time employees (13/165)
It seems like there were considerably more than the 50 employees. YTB has touted "over 300" for years and the recruiters still do.
We plan to offer ZamZuu as the exclusive IBC option for new Site Owners on a go-forward basis, while continuing to maintain and operate our existing travel IBCs. (14/165)
This is a serious statement. Going forward, a YTB Travel Network rented website is no longer an option. And Kim says the focus is still on travel. Well, OK Baghdad Bob.
We conduct marketing activities, book travel and sell a variety of products exclusively through 7,245 independent contractors known as Reps (such numbers are provided as of March 29, 2010) and 41,174 Site Owners (such numbers are provided as of December 31, 2009) (14/165)
WOW, this is quite a decline in the number of reps. One might think that a "free" opportunity might be able to attract more than 7000.
We experienced a 13.1% decrease in active Reps and a 55.4% decrease in Site Owners during 2009. (15/165)
Fees from hosting and sales of IBCs that we offer to home-based representatives make-up over 76% of our revenues as of December 31, 2009. While our business model is based primarily on IBC hosting of various products and services, we do intend to pursue other sources of revenue to lower this percentage. (15/165)
YTB appears to be concerned that this percentage will bring additional scrutiny--as it should.
We work with AT&T for Internet access. If our arrangement with this provider is terminated or if they were to cease operations, we might not be able to find an alternate provider on a timely basis or on reasonable terms, which could hurt our business. (18/165)
It is very strange to see a statement like this. It makes one wonder if they are not in default with AT&T. We have heard that many of the technology vendors are not happy about arrearages.
We increasingly utilize internet search engines to generate traffic to our IBCs. Search engines frequently update and change the logic that determines the placement and display of results of a user’s search, such that the purchased or algorithmic placement of links to our IBCs can be negatively affected. In addition, a significant amount of our business is directed to our own IBCs through our participation in pay-per-click and display advertising campaigns on internet media properties and search engines whose pricing and operating dynamics can experience rapid change, both technically and competitively. If a major search engine changes its algorithms in a manner that negatively affects the search engine ranking, paid or unpaid, of our IBCs or that of our third-party distribution partners, or if competitive dynamics further impact market pricing in a negative manner, our business and financial performance would be adversely affected. (21/165)
If true, why are Internet searchers being directed to YTB sites? When you search for anything associated with YTB, you typically get results from competitors or evidence of it being a farce/scam/pyramid scheme, etc. Why aren't the RTA/TSOs screaming at YTB for their failure to direct Internet searches to the sites for which they pay a $50/month rental fee?
Our Chairman of the Board, J. Scott Tomer, together with his family (including his father, our former Chairman, J. Lloyd Tomer) and affiliates, has the ability to influence the election and removal of the members of our board of directors and, as a result, to influence the future direction and operations of our Company. As of December 31, 2009, J. Scott Tomer, his family and affiliates beneficially owned common stock with voting power constituting approximately 44.1% of the combined voting power of our common stock (after factoring in the relative voting power of our Class A Common Stock and Class B Common Stock). Accordingly, they may significantly influence decisions concerning business opportunities, declaring dividends, issuing additional shares of common stock or other securities and the approval of any merger, consolidation or sale of all or substantially all of our assets. They may make decisions that are adverse to your interests. (28/165)
This is frightening and should be a wake up call to everyone. Coach has already moved to Florida and Scott is preparing to move.
The Agreement renews the note executed by the Company in connection with the Loan and the Note Renewal in the new amount of $1.9 million (the ― Note ‖) and extends the maturity of the Note Renewal and Loan to April 30, 2010. The amount due under the Note bears interest at a rate of 8.0% annually. A principal installment in the amount of $300,000 was due and payable on September 30, 2009, which the Company paid timely, and a second additional principal installment in the amount of $200,000, originally due and payable on December 31, 2009, was extended to January 31, 2010. To date, the Company has not made the $200,000 payment. FH Partners has not given the Company notice of its intention to accelerate the debt as a result of the Company’s failure to make the $200,000 payment that was due January 31, 2010. In the event of default, as defined in the Note, FH Partners has the right to declare the entire unpaid balance of principal and interest on the Note due and payable. (31/165)
YTB has $600K in cash and liquidity. Yet they have not paid a $200K note that is risking putting them in default. Certainly FH Partners can see the financial condition of YTB. Will they call the note and demand the $1.9M?
On May 14, 2009, a civil action was filed against the Company, three of its subsidiaries and certain executive officers of the Company in the Superior Court of Illinois, Champaign County, by the Illinois Attorney General. The complaint alleges that the defendants violated Illinois’ unfair competition and advertising laws. The Company believes it has meritorious defenses to the claims and intends to vigorously defend the case. The Company is in the process of exchanging information with the Office of the Illinois Attorney General and exploring possible resolution alternatives . (37/165)
Nothing to report here. Illinois is being tight lipped as well. Very strange indeed.
As of April 7, 2010, we had 513 shareholders of record of our Class A Common Stock and Class B Common Stock. (37/165)
Only 513 people interested in this stock? With 41K site owners and 7K reps, one might think that they could find more than 500 people to cough up a few pennies.
The value of such travel services increased approximately $9 million in 2008 to over $424 million from approximately $414 million in 2007. Comparable data for 2009 sales (retail value) has been reported to us by our travel vendors in the amount of $252 million. (39/165)
Spin, spin, spin. While most other legitimate travel companies saw an increase in travel sales in 2009 (compared to 2008) YTB saw a loss of $172M. But hey, three years ago they were up. Nice try Kim.
Comparing 2009 with 2008, total revenue was down 57.8% . Travel commissions received was down 51.5%. Income from site rentals was down 57.7%. Travel commissions paid out to the RTAs was down 58.3%. Overall, 2009’s loss was $9.8M versus $4.4M for 2008. Specifically addressing travel commissions, YTB received $12.2M in commissions and paid out $7.3M to the field. This equated to an approximate 60% split. However, in 2008, they received $25.1M and paid out $17.6M which equates to an approximate 70% split. This is strange as the “travel agent” program enabling people to earn more was rolled out in 2009. It appears that there are an insignificant number of people taking part in the program if the commission split actually decreased. This is further evidenced since their income from training was down 77.2%. (41/165)
Over 5,000 Site Owners attended the Funshine event held in Orlando, Florida in September 2008 and approximately 2,200 attended in September 2009. (43/165)
Oops.
We believe the decline in the number of new IBCs is attributed to the current economic downturn present in the United States. We anticipate slower growth in the coming months compared to what we have experienced in the past. (44/165)
Another very interesting comment. They continually say that their sustainability is tied to the revenue from the IBCs or RTA/TSOs. Here they say that they anticipate it to get worse. YTB is actually admitting that they feel it will get worse.
In addition, during 2009, we recorded impairment charges of $724,000 related to obsolete inventory and $564,000 for purchased software no longer used in operations. (46/165)
Honestly, very few companies purchase software any more. As a travel company with literally no inventory, how does one amass a $724K stock?
National Convention expense decreased $4.4 million due to costs associated with lower attendance at the convention and cost cutting measures by management. (50/165)
Lower attendance? Sure, but I am guessing that in 2009 they did not have that multi million dollar statue whose cost was funneled through Kim and Coach's little company--Beryl Martin.
The increase of $168,000 in 2009 compared to 2008 is attributable to an increase in shopYTB revenue, partially offset by a decline in revenues earned through flower sales and payment processing fees earned by the Company. (51/165)
Aha. Finally, they are mentioning flowers. It appears that YTB has indeed been including flowers, cars (if any were sold), hunting gear, beef jerky and girdles in their "travel" number. Travel Weekly...how do you feel about that?
During the fourth quarter of 2009, we performed our annual impairment test of goodwill and intangible assets pursuant to accounting standards governing goodwill and other intangible assets. As a result of our tests, we recorded an impairment charge of $450,000 related to the fair value of goodwill associated with our Travel segment. Our annual impairment test of goodwill during the fourth quarter of 2008 concluded that the goodwill of our Sunrise Travel subsidiary (purchased in 2008) with a carrying amount of $149,000 had no fair market value, resulting in an impairment charge of $149,000. See Note 9 – ―Goodwill and Intangible Assets, Net.‖ (53/165)
LOL, gee, I wonder why the "goodwill" of YTB might be impacted. My only argument is that $400K seems a little light!
The increase of $688,000 in 2009 compared to 2008 was the result of writing off $564,000 in capitalized costs for a travel booking search engine that did not perform as expected and had to be removed from production. (53/165)
I suppose this is the Convergentware. They are still booking through Travelocity as stated elsewhere in the report. But this would explain why customers do not receive the deals from their gateway or that they cannot compare trips side by side.
As of December 31, 2009, we had $678,000 in cash and cash equivalents. We believe that our cash generating capability will be adequate to meet the needs of our future operations. (57/165)
For how long? There is certainly breathing room now that PJ, Camaron, and Ron Head are out of the picture. And the additional $144K given to VanPatten is certainly less than the $600K+ given to Cauthen, Clagg, and now Tomer.
YTB has sold more than 50% of its assets in 2009 (77/165)
Deferred revenue in 2008 was $13.5M and in 2009 it was $2.9M. This is a liability and was likely reduced as a result of the terminations of Head, Jensen, Corr, Hoffmann, and other senior level Directors. (77/165)
YTB loaned Directors a lot of money and in 2009 they wrote off $371K (99/165)
The real estate transactions are VERY convoluted and interwoven. It seems if the forces go against YTB they can lose essentially all of their real estate which is their primary assets.
Travel commission revenues generated by Sunrise totaled $110,000 and $105,000 for the years ended December 31, 2009 and 2008, respectively. (109/165)
Since all transactions in Canada are being run through this agency, it seems as if they are not doing to well in Canada. There was no mention of the other Canadian offices they have in terms of generating revenue.
During 2009, the Company expended $6,000 in book royalty fees to J. Lloyd ―Coach‖ Tomer, former director and Chairman of the Board of the Company. Book royalty fees of $1,000 were included in accounts payable in the consolidated balance sheet as of December 31, 2009. (124/165)
Come on!! It was a self- published, poorly written and edited, self-serving tome to assuage the ego. The book was replete with spelling and grammatical errors. YTB ought to seek and get their $6000 back. And yes, I do have the book and yes I did read it.
As of December 31, 2009, the Company had outstanding purchase commitments for future goods and services of $1.0 million. Of these commitments, $821,000 is unconditional purchase obligations which include $722,000 related to the Company’s annual convention and $99,000 related to various travel services and technologies. (134/165)
OK, so there is $600K in cash and equivalents and they feel that is adequate. They are past due $200K from December, have two multi million dollar suits, are bleeding recruits and RTA/TSOs, have committed $722K to the America's Center and all is well? Mmmm OK.
Also on April 6, 2010, the Board of Directors adopted a resolution to modify paragraph 3.3 of the existing employment agreement effective January 1, 2008 between the Company and J. Scott Tomer, Chairman of the Board (the ― Modification ‖). Under the Modification, J. Scott Tomer will earn commissions and overrides generated by the Director 4 position occupied by a former sales director in lieu of earning commissions and overrides generated by Representative position #2. All other terms and conditions of his existing employment agreement remain unchanged. (140/165)
So, since YTB is doing so well, they bumped Scotty up closer to the top of the pyramid? I guess that is the reward he got for missing all the other growth targets.